IGEM response to Apprenticeships APPG: Call for evidence - Apprenticeships and the Industrial Strategy
IGEM has responded to the All-Party Parliamentary Group (APPG) on Apprenticeships' inquiry on 'How can apprenticeships support the ambition of economic growth via the Industrial Strategy?', highlighting the need for a skills system that supports both new entrants and the upskilling of the existing workforce.
Our response to the Call for Evidence focuses on those questions best suited to IGEM’s expertise.
Introduction
The Industrial Strategy identifies eight growth sectors as the engines of the economy and its future success. Central to this vision is a workforce equipped with the appropriate technical skills. Following the transition to the Growth and Skills Levy, the APPG is seeking understand how the skills system can be optimised to meet these strategic goals.
Strategic alignment
1. To what extent do you welcome the skills reforms initiated by this Government? Please rate on a scale of 1–10, where 1 = do not welcome at all, and 10 = fully welcome the reforms.
9
2. Set out your initial view on the performance of Skills England and its policy development process.
While IGEM welcomes the creation of Skills England and its focus on aligning skills provision with economic need, we note concerns raised by employers that the volume and pace of recent reforms has outstripped industry's ability to adapt. For sectors supporting the energy transition, there is a need for sustained engagement with employers, professional institutions and standards-setting bodies to ensure that skills reforms support, rather than inadvertently hinder, workforce planning and investment. A stronger employer voice within skills policymaking will help ensure that emerging workforce requirements for clean energy, gas infrastructure, hydrogen and industrial decarbonisation are appropriately reflected.
3. How important are apprenticeships to delivery and innovation within the Government’s Industrial Strategy? Please rate on a scale of 1–10, where 1 = Not important at all, and 10 = Extremely important.
10
4. How closely do the current Apprenticeship Standards reflect the specific technical requirements of the eight priority sectors identified in the Industrial Strategy? How responsive is Skills England to skills needs in these sectors?
Current Apprenticeship Standards provide an important foundation for the Industrial Strategy’s priority sectors, particularly in engineering, construction, digital and manufacturing occupations that cut across clean energy industries. However, the clean energy transition will not be delivered solely through new entrants. A significant proportion of the future workforce is already in employment and will need structured opportunities to upskill, reskill or cross-skill into adjacent low-carbon technologies, including hydrogen, biomethane, CCUS, clean heat, energy efficiency and future gas infrastructure. This is particularly relevant to the gas sector, where existing engineers and technicians already possess transferable technical, safety and systems knowledge, but will require additional training to operate confidently across emerging technologies.
There is a strong evidence base for this approach. Skills England’s Sector Skills Needs Assessment for Clean Energy states that clean energy priority occupations are projected to grow substantially between 2025 and 2030, that many priority occupations are shared with sectors such as construction, advanced manufacturing and defence, and that level 2 and 3 apprenticeships are historically important routes into clean energy priority occupations. It also identifies high demand for STEM, skilled trades and managerial roles, with technical skills including inspecting, testing, installing and maintaining equipment being particularly relevant.
For IGEM, the key point is that Apprenticeship Standards must remain responsive to both new clean energy roles and the adaptation of existing safety-critical occupations. Current standards should therefore be reviewed with employers, professional engineering institutions, training providers and sector bodies to ensure they reflect whole-system energy knowledge, practical competence, safety assurance, digitalisation and the realities of working with gaseous fuels and energy infrastructure.
Apprenticeships should support young people to enter existing industries with a credible pathway into clean energy, but they should also enable experienced workers to transition safely into new technologies without requiring unnecessary duplication of training.
5. How can the Local Skills Improvement Plans (LSIPs) be better integrated with national Industrial Strategy goals to prevent regional skills disparities?
Local Skills Improvement Plans should act as the bridge between national industrial priorities and the skills needs of local employers. To achieve this, LSIPs need stronger, more consistent alignment with national workforce strategies, including the Clean Energy Jobs Plan, the Industrial Strategy sector plans and Skills England’s sector skills assessments. This would help ensure that local provision is not developed in isolation, but is connected to a clear national view of where future jobs, technologies and infrastructure investment are expected to emerge.
A coordinated approach is particularly important for clean energy because future demand will vary significantly by region, reflecting differences in infrastructure, supply chains, housing stock, industrial clusters and local economic strengths. Skills England’s Clean Energy Sector Skills Needs Assessment shows that clean energy employment is expected to grow across all English regions by 2030, but at different scales and with different occupational profiles. This reinforces the need for LSIPs to reflect local opportunity while avoiding fragmented provision or regional gaps in access to training.
For apprentices, this means connecting training supply to real labour market demand. Apprentices should be able to see that the qualification they are undertaking leads to viable employment in their local area or region, while employers should be able to access the training routes required to support growth. LSIPs should therefore include clearer mechanisms for mapping local training provision against projected sector demand, identifying gaps in apprenticeship availability, and ensuring that colleges and independent training providers have the confidence and resources to invest in relevant equipment, tutors and employer partnerships.
Funding and Levy reform
7. What is your view of the Growth and Skills Levy and, if it should be improved, how?
IGEM welcomes the principle of greater flexibility in the skills system, particularly where it enables employers to invest in upskilling and reskilling existing workers for clean energy roles. The Growth and Skills Levy should support full apprenticeship programmes as well as shorter, high-quality units or modular training where these meet a clearly defined occupational need. However, flexibility should not come at the expense of quality, occupational competence or the integrity of apprenticeship pathways in safety-critical sectors.
The clean energy transition makes this flexibility essential. DESNZ’s Clean Energy Jobs Plan states that the majority of the 2030 workforce is already in employment, meaning that policy must support clear routes for workers to transfer across sectors and improve their skills. This is directly relevant to gas, where existing workers may need additional competence in hydrogen-ready systems, biomethane, digital monitoring, safety assurance and new installation or maintenance practices.
IGEM is concerned that the removal of Level 7 apprenticeship funding could restrict opportunities for experienced professionals to reskill for emerging clean energy roles. As much of the workforce needed to deliver net zero is already in employment, the skills system should support both new entrants and higher-level workforce transition where there is a clear strategic need.
We welcome reforms which allow employers, including SMEs, to fund training for existing workers where a full apprenticeship is not proportionate. This could include units linked to occupational standards, bridging modules for experienced workers, and training that supports safe transition into clean energy technologies.
Government should also protect funding for full apprenticeship programmes, because these remain critical for developing the pipeline of new technicians, engineers and skilled tradespeople needed across the Industrial Strategy sectors.
Delivery
12. To what extent do you see apprenticeship units as meeting the upskilling needs of innovative sectors compared to full apprenticeship programmes?
Apprenticeship units could be highly valuable for innovative and fast-changing sectors, especially where experienced workers need to acquire specific additional competences rather than undertake a full apprenticeship from the beginning. For the gas and clean energy sectors, this could include targeted upskilling in hydrogen, biomethane, CCUS, digital network monitoring, energy efficiency, clean heat and new safety procedures. This type of modular provision could help employers respond more quickly to technology change while making training more accessible to workers who are already in employment.
However, units should complement rather than replace full apprenticeship programmes. Full apprenticeships remain essential for developing occupational competence, especially for new entrants and roles where competence depends on a broad combination of knowledge, skills, behaviours and supervised workplace experience. Shorter units may be appropriate for defined upskilling needs, but they must be designed around employer-led occupational standards and should be quality-assured so that employers, regulators and learners can trust the outcome.
In safety-critical sectors, the distinction is particularly important. Training that supports the energy transition must not create a fragmented system in which workers accumulate disconnected units without a clear competence framework. Apprenticeship units should therefore be mapped to recognised occupational standards, professional competence requirements and, where relevant, regulated certification or registration routes.
13. Please set out your view on the Government’s reform of End-Point Assessment.
IGEM supports efforts to make apprenticeship assessment more proportionate and less burdensome, but reform must protect independent, rigorous assessment where public safety, system resilience and occupational competence are at stake. In safety-critical sectors such as gas, energy infrastructure and construction, the assessment system must provide confidence that an apprentice can perform the role safely and competently in real working conditions.
Skills England’s Requirements and guidance for apprenticeship assessment states that assessment reforms are intended to remain grounded in sector expertise and employer confidence, demonstrate full occupational competence, maintain quality including in safety-critical roles, and ensure apprentices continue to learn all knowledge, skills and behaviours in the occupational standard. This principle should be strongly maintained as assessment plans are revised.
For the gas sector, independent assessment and robust competence assurance are not simply administrative steps; they are integral to public safety and consumer protection. Existing gas competence frameworks include routes such as Apprenticeship Standards, Managed Learning Programmes, the Nationally Accredited Certification Scheme for Individual Gas Fitting Operatives, and the Group Competence Scheme. Any reform should therefore be developed with sector bodies and regulatory stakeholders to avoid weakening confidence in competence, particularly where assessment interacts with licence-to-practise or registration requirements.
14. How can SMEs be incentivised to take on apprentices?
SMEs are essential to expanding apprenticeship opportunities, particularly in skilled trades and local supply chains, but many face practical and financial barriers. These include the cost of supervision, reduced productivity while apprentices are learning, administrative complexity, limited HR capacity and in some cases, concerns that once trained, apprentices may move to competitors. For smaller employers, these barriers can be significant enough to prevent participation even where there is a genuine need for future skills.
Government should therefore consider a package of SME support that goes beyond direct wage or training subsidies. This could include targeted financial incentives, simplified onboarding processes, local apprenticeship brokerage, shared apprenticeship models, mentoring support and help with apprentice supervision. In clean energy and safety-critical sectors, SMEs may also need support to access specialist equipment, competent instructors and assessment infrastructure, so that apprentices receive high-quality training without placing disproportionate burdens on small employers.
For the gas sector specifically, SMEs should be supported to participate in both the future workforce pipeline and the reskilling of existing workers. Larger employers may have internal training capacity, but smaller supply-chain businesses often rely on external provision and local partnerships. Without targeted support for SMEs, there is a risk that clean energy opportunities and apprenticeship pathways become concentrated among larger employers, limiting regional access and weakening the overall skills pipeline.
15. How can schools’ careers advice be improved to promote the apprenticeships pathway?
Careers advice should introduce engineering, skilled trades and energy careers much earlier in the school journey, rather than presenting apprenticeships as a late-stage option or a secondary alternative to university. Pupils should be able to understand from a young age how science, technology, engineering and maths connect to real-world challenges such as energy security, net zero, clean heat, hydrogen, biomethane and safe infrastructure.
IGEM’s own skills and outreach work recognises the importance of increasing awareness of the gas sector, innovation and its role in a low-carbon energy system, and of inspiring interest among young people and career transition populations. This should be reflected more broadly in careers education, with apprenticeships presented as high-value technical routes into meaningful, future-ready work.
Practical employer engagement is particularly important. Schools should have better access to engineers, technicians, apprentices and employers who can explain what roles involve, what skills are required and how apprenticeships can lead to progression. IGEM’s outreach experience also shows the value of hands-on activities, visual materials, careers fairs, direct engagement with engineers and clearer presentation of career pathways.
Careers advice should also reflect the breadth of future clean energy roles. The clean energy workforce will require plumbers and heating installers, electricians, engineering technicians, project managers, digital specialists, safety professionals and many others. Presenting this range clearly would help young people understand that apprenticeships are not narrow or limiting routes, but credible pathways into skilled, well-paid and socially valuable careers.
16. To what extent are local authorities and other devolved government structures responsible for the success of the apprenticeships system? Please rate on a scale of 1–10, where 1 = not at all responsible, and 10 = highly responsible.
10