IGEM response to House of Lords Environment and Climate Change Committee Inquiry: Dunkelflaute and the risks of renewable energy intermittency
IGEM has responded to the House of Lords Environment and Climate Change Committee inquiry on Dunkelflaute and the risks of renewable energy intermittency.
Overarching position
Dunkelflaute is a whole-energy-system resilience challenge, not simply an electricity-generation problem. IGEM supports the transition to a low-carbon, renewables-led electricity system. However, increasing dependence on weather-variable generation makes flexibility, storage and firm dispatchable capacity increasingly important, particularly during prolonged periods of simultaneously low wind and solar output. Addressing this challenge requires a portfolio of complementary solutions operating over different timescales, rather than reliance on any single technology.
Existing gas infrastructure represents a significant resilience asset. Its role in supporting peak capacity, energy storage and flexibility should be recognised alongside its annual energy throughput. In practical terms, electricity-system resilience is closely linked to the resilience of the gas system. Low-carbon gases can progressively decarbonise this function: biomethane is renewable, storable and dispatchable, while hydrogen offers the potential to convert surplus low-carbon electricity into a storable energy vector for later use during periods of scarcity.
The central policy challenge is therefore not simply to install sufficient renewable generating capacity, but to establish a balanced, integrated energy system capable of moving energy across time and between energy vectors. Investment must be balanced across asset types to deliver the lowest-cost system for homes and businesses. Focusing only on electricity generation and storage risks creating an underutilised and unnecessarily expensive system.
1. How are Dunkelflaute events defined and how far in advance can they be predicted? How likely is it that the UK will be impacted by Dunkelflaute events lasting days to weeks and is that likelihood expected to change in the future?
There is no single accepted definition of Dunkelflaute beyond a period of simultaneously low wind and solar generation. The duration or generation threshold used to identify an event varies between institutions, system operators and companies. For energy planning purposes, IGEM considers the more relevant issue to be the scale and duration of the residual energy requirement when weather-dependent generation is insufficient, particularly where this coincides with high demand or consecutive periods of inadequate renewable generation.
Recent research involving European transmission system operators supports this approach. It suggests that measures based on residual load, reflecting the gap between electricity demand and renewable generation, are more effective at identifying potential system shortages than renewable generation or demand alone. From a security-of-supply perspective, the critical issue is therefore not simply how far wind and solar output falls, but the remaining energy requirement that must be supplied from other sources.
Environmental Research: Energy 2, [Evaluation of ‘Dunkelflaute’ event detection methods considering grid operators’ needs](), April 2025
Such events are not hypothetical. In November 2024, prolonged calm and cloudy weather across the UK led to a sustained reduction in wind generation for much of the month. Longer-term analysis indicates that multi-day low-wind events lasting at least 14 consecutive days occur approximately every five years,1 with longer events also recorded. A 35-day low-wind period occurred between mid-August and mid-September 2022, while a further 19-day event took place in April 2022 during an extended heating season.2
[https://www.rmets.org/publications/reports-and-briefing-papers/energy/state-climate-uk-energy-sector-2024-25]()
Low-wind risk should not necessarily be considered as a series of isolated events. Research examining 72 years of weather data for Great Britain highlights the importance of pooling wind droughts separated by relatively short recovery periods. Defining a wind drought only as an uninterrupted spell below a threshold can be misleading because a brief recovery in generation may not fully reset the system before another low-wind period, particularly where stored energy or other forms of flexibility have already been drawn down.
University of Oxford, [Extreme value analysis of wind droughts in Great Britain](), December 2023
There is no authoritative evidence that predicts future UK Dunkelflaute periods. NESO has identified gaps in understanding their frequency, duration and geographical extent, particularly where they coincide with cold-weather peaks. Its extreme-weather modelling project sought to improve these assumptions and their use in the Future Energy Scenarios, but concluded that a more comprehensive weather dataset is needed to select and test events against different system designs.
NESO, [Extreme Weather and Climate Modelling (Dunkelflaute)](), June 2025
Resilience planning should therefore test credible multi-day and multi-week scenarios rather than treating intermittency principally as an hourly balancing issue.
2. How significant could the future demand-supply gap be during a Dunkelflaute in 2030 and 2050, under current plans and targets? Is the UK on track to deliver the infrastructure required to address these gaps?
IGEM is aware of modelling of the potential 2030 and 2050 electricity systems and their flexibility requirements, alongside a growing body of research on the frequency, duration and energy deficit associated with Dunkelflaute. However, IGEM has not identified a recent authoritative assessment that provides a definitive demand-supply gap for multi-day and multi-week UK Dunkelflaute scenarios in both 2030 and 2050 under current policy assumptions.
Recent Energy Systems Catapult modelling provides an indication of the scale of the challenge. Using 44 years of historic weather data from 1980 to 2024, it models electricity supply and demand hour by hour under four future energy-system scenarios and explicitly considers a 14-day Peak Duration Gap associated with prolonged low renewable generation. The modelling indicates a Peak Duration Gap of approximately 9-9.5 TWh in 2030, rising to around 11 TWh by 2040 in some scenarios, alongside a Peak Daily Gap of approximately 31-34 GW in 2030.
Energy Systems Catapult, [Innovating to Net Zero 2026: Scaling flexibility to meet the five peaks challenge](), February 2026
This illustrates that adequate generating capacity is not sufficient in itself. The system must also have enough stored or dispatchable energy to sustain output throughout an extended event. The analysis further indicates that flexibility requirements grow as electrification and renewable generation increase: electricity consumption rises by as much as 10% by 2030 and 70-80% by 2040 in the scenarios modelled, with significant flexibility requirements across all four scenarios.
NESO’s dedicated extreme-weather modelling project sought to improve the representation of Dunkelflaute risks in future energy-system analysis. Although the project was unable to model these risks accurately, its conclusions help to identify the remaining knowledge gaps.
IGEM therefore considers that further analysis should quantify both the maximum residual power requirement in GW and the cumulative energy deficit in GWh or TWh under credible prolonged Dunkelflaute scenarios. This distinction is particularly important when comparing short-duration flexibility with technologies capable of supplying energy over days or weeks.
Electricity and gas systems should be modelled together, including electricity storage, demand-side response, interconnectors, dispatchable generation, nuclear power, gas storage and linepack, and biomethane and hydrogen production and storage. This would allow Government to assess not only how much generating capacity is required, but whether sufficient stored energy and associated infrastructure would be available to sustain it throughout a prolonged event.
3. Which low-carbon technologies are most effective at addressing long-term Dunkelflaute events, lasting days to weeks? At what point could these technologies be deployed at a system-wide level and what are the main barriers to their deployment?
IGEM does not consider that there is a single solution, as different technologies address different durations and parts of the system.
Biomethane is particularly valuable because it is renewable, storable, dispatchable and not weather dependent. It can use existing gas infrastructure and contribute to firm energy supply during renewable shortfalls. NESO’s recent report, Exploring the Role of Biomethane in the Energy System to 2050, recognises its strategic and operational value as a flexible fuel during system stress and low-wind conditions. This now needs to be reflected in Government policy. Barriers include the absence of a stable, long-term policy and regulatory framework centred on continued investment support beyond the Green Gas Support Scheme and zero-rating within the UK Emissions Trading Scheme.
NESO, [Exploring the Role of Biomethane in the Energy System to 2050](https://committees.parliament.uk/submission/3974/), July 2026
Hydrogen has significant potential to provide long-duration and cross-vector flexibility. Flexible electrolysis can absorb electricity during periods of renewable surplus, after which hydrogen can be stored and used for industrial demand or flexible power generation. Current barriers include the delayed Hydrogen Strategy, the delayed outcome of the Transport and Storage Business Model and the associated award of the first Regional Hydrogen Network. Hydrogen-to-power must therefore be considered alongside the pipeline and storage infrastructure required to make it operational; considering generating plant without transport and storage risks delay, restricted learning and slower subsequent scale-up.
Gas-fired dispatchable generation using progressively lower-carbon fuels and/or CCS can provide firm capacity when shorter-duration flexibility resources are exhausted. Flexible hydrogen or gas generation, with and without CCS during the transition, should therefore be considered alongside short-duration flexibility and storage.
Gas storage and network linepack should be recognised as energy-storage resources rather than overlooked because they are not electricity-storage technologies. Linepack is one of the most important forms of short-term gas flexibility in Great Britain, delivering approximately 100 TWh of annual cumulative storage across the gas networks, with theoretical capacity significantly higher. IGEM’s own research estimates that gas pipeline storage capacity across transmission and distribution exceeds 1,700 GWh.3
[https://zenodo.org/records/5846323](https://www.carbontrust.com/our-work-and-impact/guides-reports-and-tools/flexibility-in-great-britain)
Batteries and consumer flexibility remain important, particularly for short-duration balancing and peak management. However, Dunkelflaute lasting days or weeks require assets capable of supplying energy for substantially longer periods. IGEM welcomes the Government’s Ultra-Long Duration Energy Storage Challenge, particularly its inclusion of hydrogen technologies, but considers that it may define resilience too narrowly around electricity-storage technologies rather than the storage of low-carbon energy more broadly. Future long-duration flexibility and energy-security innovation funding should assess stored renewable gas and dispatchable renewable-gas generation on a whole-system, technology-neutral basis.
Government should assess technologies according to duration, dispatchability, energy capacity and whole-system value, not simply installed electrical capacity.
4. What role will gas with carbon capture or other dispatchable generation need to play during a severe Dunkelflaute? What are the challenges associated with installing carbon capture for retained gas plants?
A system that depends heavily on weather-variable renewables will continue to require some form of firm, dispatchable generation, particularly during prolonged cold and still conditions. The longer-term question is how that function is progressively decarbonised. Potential pathways include gas generation equipped with CCS, hydrogen-to-power and dispatchable renewable gases such as biomethane.
Biomethane offers a distinctive opportunity to combine dispatchable low-carbon power with greenhouse gas removals. The high-purity biogenic CO₂ separated during biomethane production can be captured and permanently stored, including through non-pipeline transport routes, enabling negative emissions without requiring post-combustion carbon capture at the power station. If biomethane is subsequently used for power generation with PCCC, further biogenic CO₂ can be captured, substantially increasing the GGR opportunity. Green Gas Taskforce analysis estimates potential removals of 17.1 MtCO₂ per year by 2050 from biogas upgrading and a further 20.6 MtCO₂ per year from biomethane power with CCUS under its illustrative scenario.
Green Gas Taskforce, [Biomethane GGRs](), August 2025
The Independent Review of Greenhouse Gas Removals, chaired by Dr Alan Whitehead, supports enabling CO₂ from biogas upgrading to access GGR support and accelerating non-pipeline CO₂ transport, which will be particularly important for geographically dispersed biomethane plants.
DESNZ, [Independent review on greenhouse gas removals](), July 2026
This opportunity is becoming increasingly deliverable as UK CO₂ transport and storage infrastructure develops. The East Coast Cluster transport and storage network has moved into construction, while construction of the HyNet CO₂ pipeline began in 2025, creating infrastructure that could support a growing market for captured CO₂ and permanent geological storage.
Government’s approach to firm power should therefore treat natural gas with CCS, hydrogen-to-power and biomethane-fired generation as potentially complementary technologies rather than direct substitutes. Biomethane warrants explicit recognition because it combines renewable energy, dispatchability during prolonged low-wind and low-solar periods, and the potential for permanent carbon removals. The objective should not simply be to retain sufficient gas-fired capacity to manage Dunkelflaute, but progressively to transform that capacity into a low-carbon and, where practical, negative-emissions resilience resource.
Infrastructure decisions must be coordinated. CO₂ transport and storage, hydrogen infrastructure, future gas networks and generating capacity should be considered as components of the same system architecture rather than through separate policy processes. Government must also recognise the value of retaining assets that may operate at lower annual load factors but provide high resilience value during rare events.
5. What is the role of demand management in shifting or reducing the demand-supply gap during extended Dunkelflaute events?
Demand flexibility can make an important contribution, but during prolonged Dunkelflaute it should be regarded as one element of the resilience portfolio rather than a substitute for adequate firm supply.
The Carbon Trust’s Flexibility in Great Britain report modelled a 2050 extreme-weather week with very cold temperatures and very low wind. In its electric-heating scenario, non-domestic demand-side response shifted demand within the day, reducing morning and evening peaks by up to 11 GW and moving demand into overnight periods. This demonstrates the potential for short-duration demand shifting to reduce system stress and the back-up generating capacity required to maintain adequacy.
The Carbon Trust, [Flexibility in Great Britain](), May 2021
Consumer-led flexibility is expected to become increasingly important as heating and transport electrify. Smart-controlled hybrid systems can provide cross-vector flexibility by changing the balance between electricity and gas consumption when the electricity system is under stress. Such systems could temporarily switch demand from electricity to gas, biomethane or, in future, hydrogen until a constraint or supply shortfall has passed.
However, shifting demand by a few hours is fundamentally different from ensuring adequate energy availability throughout a prolonged, multi-day weather event. Policy must therefore distinguish short-duration demand flexibility from long-duration energy adequacy. Biomethane and hydrogen could increasingly provide this flexibility with low-carbon gases, although exceptional periods may remain in which limited natural gas use is required to maintain secure energy supplies.
Rather than requiring the complete elimination of natural gas during these rare events, Government should consider whether a defined and progressively reducing residual-emissions tolerance is appropriate where this demonstrably provides essential system resilience. Such an approach should distinguish routine unabated fossil-fuel use from limited strategic use during low-probability, high-impact events, while retaining a clear net-zero trajectory. It should be evidence-led, appropriately limited and prioritise biomethane, hydrogen and other low-carbon alternatives as their availability increases.
6. How important is international cooperation on electricity supply for resilience to Dunkelflaute events? What are the barriers to further cooperation?
International cooperation is vital, and interconnection can substantially mitigate Dunkelflaute. However, it cannot remove the need for domestic flexibility because geographically extensive weather events can affect neighbouring European systems simultaneously. NESO has specifically identified the geographical extent of Dunkelflaute as an area requiring improved understanding.
A Government Office for Science roundtable chaired by the Met Office Chief Scientist emphasised that the large spatial scale of wind droughts means deficits can occur simultaneously across the UK and Europe, potentially limiting the extent to which interconnection can compensate. It highlighted the need to assess the resilience of the UK system to compound low-wind and low-solar events.
Government Office for Science, [How well do we understand the impacts of weather conditions on the UK’s renewable wind and solar energy supplies?](), November 2023
This risk is not purely theoretical. Electricity flows through interconnectors respond to conditions on both sides of the connection and do not represent guaranteed supply to Great Britain. Norway’s hydropower-dominated system provides valuable flexibility through the 1.4 GW North Sea Link, whose trading arrangements generally move electricity from the lower-price to the higher-price market. However, Norway reserves the ability to protect its own security of supply, and restrictions may be imposed on foreign connections where there is a real risk of domestic energy shortages. During simultaneous European system stress, exports cannot therefore be assumed to remain available to Great Britain at nominal interconnector capacity.
Energy Connections, [Norway’s Power Supply to Europe Threatened by Low Hydro Levels](), October 2025
Interconnectors should therefore form part of a diversified resilience portfolio alongside sufficient domestic storage, demand flexibility, dispatchable low-carbon generation and renewable gases. International cooperation should also extend beyond electricity to future hydrogen markets, gas storage and interconnected low-carbon gas infrastructure, which could provide further diversity and resilience.
7. What analysis has been done to identify the most cost-effective approach to maintaining security of supply and meeting electricity demand under long-term Dunkelflaute conditions?
The most cost-effective approach should be determined on a whole-energy-system basis rather than through electricity-system modelling alone. Imperial College London’s research demonstrates the importance of modelling interactions between energy vectors and sources of flexibility when optimising future system design.
Imperial College London, [Whole Energy System Modelling for Heat Decarbonisation](), August 2021
More recent Imperial modelling of Britain’s 2050 net-zero electricity and gas transmission systems considers resilience to extreme weather and identifies synergies between electricity, hydrogen, storage and gas-network linepack in providing flexibility, security and resilience.
Advances in Applied Energy, [The impact of hydrogen on decarbonisation and resilience in integrated energy systems](), November 2024
This supports assessing electricity storage, demand flexibility and interconnection alongside hydrogen, biomethane, gas storage, linepack and dispatchable generation rather than evaluating each vector independently. Analysis should consider both the cost of providing flexibility and the avoided whole-system costs associated with different infrastructure combinations, recognising that some assets may provide substantial resilience value despite low annual utilisation.
Carbon Trust analysis, underpinned by Imperial College London’s Integrated Whole Energy System model, optimised electricity, gas, hydrogen, heat, storage and CCS together while meeting carbon and security-of-supply constraints. The modelling included a 72-hour extreme cold-weather event coinciding with wind and solar output below 5% of maximum. Across all three 2050 pathways examined, additional flexibility reduced total system costs by £9.6-16.7 billion per year.
Carbon Trust analysis[13](https://www.carbontrust.com/our-work-and-impact/guides-reports-and-tools/flexibility-in-great-britain)
The analysis also demonstrates the value of cross-vector flexibility during system stress. In its high-flexibility hybrid-heating pathway, limited use of gas for heat substantially reduces the electricity-generating capacity required compared with the fully electric pathway. Cost-effectiveness assessments should therefore capture total system costs and resilience value rather than comparing technologies principally by their individual generation costs. The relevant comparison is not simply £/MWh of wind against £/MWh of dispatchable generation, but the cost of delivering an energy system capable of meeting demand reliably during normal conditions and prolonged renewable droughts.
8. Do current market arrangements provide sufficient incentives for investment in the range of solutions needed to maintain security of supply during Dunkelflaute conditions? Do market arrangements support the establishment of a strategic reserve?
Current arrangements do not provide sufficient incentives. They risk undervaluing existing resilience assets and limiting the market potential of low-carbon gases in mitigating Dunkelflaute risk. IGEM supports an aligned, long-term plan for strategic dispatchable capacity and for the gas system required to supply it, including explicit recognition of the importance of gas storage and the value of linepack.
A strategic reserve cannot be considered solely in terms of generating plant. Government must also establish whether the necessary fuel production, storage, transport and network capacity will be available when reserve generation is called upon. Market arrangements should increasingly recognise and reward long-duration energy availability, dispatchability, strategic storage, cross-vector flexibility and resilience during low-probability, high-impact events.
Support mechanisms for electrolytic hydrogen should reward wider system outcomes, including reduced curtailment, increased flexibility, resilience and energy security, rather than valuing hydrogen production volumes alone. As set out in response to Question 3, biomethane also requires a long-term policy and regulatory framework, continued investment support beyond the Green Gas Support Scheme and zero-rating within the UK Emissions Trading Scheme.
9. What key decisions does Government need to take before 2030 in relation to long-duration energy storage and low-carbon dispatchable power?
Before 2030, Government should determine the volume and duration of firm energy capability required to withstand credible multi-day and multi-week renewable shortfalls. It should clarify the role retained gas generation will play through and beyond 2030, and how that capacity will transition progressively towards low-carbon fuels and/or CCS.
Government must also determine the hydrogen-to-power capability required and support it through a credible programme for hydrogen production, pipelines and storage rather than treating power stations in isolation. Biomethane should be incorporated into electricity-security planning as a domestic, renewable and dispatchable source of energy, rather than treated only as a means of decarbonising the gas system.
Decisions are also needed on how existing gas storage and linepack will be valued and maintained during the transition, how long-duration electricity storage, gas storage and hydrogen storage should interact, and how markets will reward assets that are used infrequently but are strategically necessary.
Most importantly, Government should establish an integrated whole-energy-system strategy spanning 2030 to 2050. Clean Power 2030 is an intermediate milestone, and the resilience infrastructure built or retired to meet it will influence the UK’s ability to deliver net zero securely and affordably by 2050.
A key strategic question is whether electrification is treated as the objective of the transition or as one of the tools for delivering the UK’s overarching net-zero objective. IGEM considers the latter approach essential. Prioritising emissions reduction, while allowing electricity, biomethane, hydrogen, storage and other flexibility options to compete on their whole-system contribution, provides greater scope to achieve net zero while protecting resilience and managing costs.
10. What best practice can be learned from other countries about the innovative use of technologies for managing the risk of intermittency from renewables?
Denmark: integrating renewable electricity, renewable gas and storage
Denmark demonstrates the value of treating electricity and gas as complementary parts of a highly renewable energy system rather than pursuing the decarbonisation of individual vectors in isolation. Energinet’s Danish Biomethane Experiences identifies biomethane as supporting security of supply because it is indigenous and storable, while providing flexibility that enables greater integration of wind and solar. Denmark has adapted its gas infrastructure as biomethane production has increased, including reverse-flow capability from distribution to transmission networks so that surplus production that cannot be consumed locally can access the wider gas system.
Energinet, [Danish Biomethane Experiences](), September 2022
Denmark also maintains underground gas storage to buffer seasonal demand alongside its wind-led electricity and increasingly renewable gas systems. The lesson for the UK is the value of coordinated system design: weather-dependent renewable electricity can be complemented by storable renewable gases, with networks and storage adapted to maximise the availability and system value of those resources.
Germany: planning for extended renewable droughts
Germany provides a useful example of planning for Dunkelflaute through a portfolio of firm capacity, storage and increasingly low-carbon fuels, rather than assuming that renewable capacity and short-duration flexibility alone will provide security of supply. Its 2026 Power Plant Strategy provides for 12 GW of new controllable capacity, of which 10 GW must meet a long-duration criterion and be capable of generating continuously for extended periods for security-of-supply purposes. New plants supported under the strategy will be hydrogen-ready and required to decarbonise fully by 2045.
German Federal Ministry for Economic Affairs and Energy, [Agreement in principle with the European Commission on key points of the power plant strategy](), January 2026
Germany is also moving towards a wider technology-neutral capacity mechanism that recognises the need to remunerate generation, storage and demand-side flexibility for their availability. The lesson for the UK is that a highly renewable system still requires an explicit mechanism for securing firm, long-duration capacity. Assets that operate infrequently in normal conditions can nevertheless provide substantial system value as insurance against prolonged renewable scarcity. Policy must therefore consider both how that capacity is remunerated and how its fuel supply can progressively decarbonise.
Wider Europe: geographical balancing helps but does not remove the need for domestic resilience
European research demonstrates the benefits of combining wind and solar across larger geographical areas, while also showing that extreme renewable droughts remain relevant even with interconnection. Recent modelling using 35 historical weather years found substantial long-duration storage requirements in its least-cost European system despite assuming policy-relevant levels of interconnection.
[Long-duration electricity storage needs for coping with Dunkelflaute events in Europe](), April 2026
This cautions against treating imports as guaranteed firm capacity during prolonged, geographically widespread weather events. Interconnection remains valuable, but should complement rather than substitute for domestic storage, demand flexibility and firm low-carbon generation. Overall, international experience supports a diversified resilience portfolio. The UK should avoid disproportionate reliance on any single technology or energy vector and instead optimise renewable generation, renewable and low-carbon gases, storage, demand flexibility, interconnection and firm generation on a whole-system basis.